Institute for Individual Investors

Member Login
36 votes
Thumbs Up! Thumbs Down!
Thank you for voting!

Fed Flashes Warning Signal

Friday, June 22, 2012 | Ed Pawelec

Famed LSD advocate and Harvard Professor Dr. Timothy Leary passed away on May 31, 1996, but the practitioners of his philosophy, "The only hope is dope," live on at the Federal Reserve. 

The market's response to Wednesday's Fed policy statement and subsequent press conference by Bennie “The Bong Master” Bernanke suggests that confidence in the Central Bank is waning.

Bennie freely admitted that the Central Bank, after the completion of the $267 billion Twist 2 at the end of this year, would be out of ammunition as far as maturities extensions go.  Quoting from the New York Fed, who will be implementing the sale of short maturities and purchase of longer dated treasuries:

"Once the maturity extension program is completed, the Federal reserve will hold almost no securities maturing through January 2016."

So that's one less form of monetary dope that Bennie will be peddling.  Frighteningly for investors, Bernanke thinks he has other weapons at his disposal that can save the economy, but I believe he is completely out of touch, and cash may be the best play available if you can't short the market.


I Think I'm Turning Japanese

During the press conference, which is always the most entertaining part of the circus, a Japanese reporter, whose name I did not catch, questioned the chairman as to whether or not he felt he was essentially creating a liquidity trap.  That's a situation where Central Bank monetary injections fail to have the desired effect of stimulating the economy.  Bennie replied:

"The U.S. economy is in a situation where short term interest rates are close to zero.  So what that means is that the Federal Reserve cannot add monetary accommodation by cutting short term interest rates, the usual approach.  It's been one of the themes of my own work for a long time, including the work I did on the Bank of Japan, that central banks are not out of tools once the short term interest rate hits zero.  There are other additional steps that can be taken and we have demonstrated through both communications techniques, guidance about future policy, which is something the Japanese have done as well, and through asset purchases, also something the Bank of Japan has done, that central banks do have some ability to provide financial accommodation to support the recovery even when short term interest rates are close to zero ...  But I do think it can be effective in helping the economy."

Apparently, the work he did for the Bank of Japan did not include the evaluation of the effectiveness of such measures.  Over the last decade and change, Japan's central bank has not only purchased its own treasuries, but expanded the accommodative policies to include purchases of ETFs on the Japanese stock market as well as real estate investment trusts (REITs).  The results have mired the country in a no-growth, deflationary spiral, and few would argue with that. 

I'm not sure how anyone could possibly characterize that as effective policy, unless they are completely inebriated. 


The Money is Where?

A few minutes later, another reporter gave Bernanke the opportunity to confirm the fact that his over reliance on monetary theory has clouded his vision.  The question related to whether or not Operation Twist and other forms of quantitative easing will have a continued negative impact on bank earnings and, as a result, impede the ability of consumers to get credit from said banks.  At first, he even seemed a little confused by the question...

"Credit to consumers?  No I don't think so.  I've heard the argument that when you lower interest rates you make it unattractive to lend.  I don't think that is quite right.  What we are lowering is the safe interest rate, the treasury rate.  That should make it even more attractive for banks, rather than to hold securities, to look for borrowers and to earn the spread between the safe rate and what they can earn by lending to households and businesses.  So I think macro (sic) policy and fiscal policy can support lending.  Now the question arises in some contexts whether there are other barriers to lending, as exists for example in some parts of the mortgage market.  But lower interest rates on securities and other types of assets, all else being equal, would induce banks to look for higher yielding returns, higher yielding assets in the form of loans to households and businesses."

There are so many things wrong with this answer, but I will try and keep it brief.  According to the St. Louis Federal Reserve, since the announcement of the first round of quantitative easing was announced in August of 2008, commercial and industrial loans are down 10%.  Now it is true that this is up from the lows set in October of 2010 when business lending was off 21% from the announcement of QE, but banks are clearly not actively searching to make new loans.

Banks make risky bets with excess cash.  Jamie Dimon said as much during his recent testimony on Capitol Hill.  Banks are looking for higher returns, but they are not looking for the measly few percentage points they can get by putting the money to work in the economy by making loans.  They are swinging for the fences and double-digit returns through speculation in obscure derivatives.


Pack Another One, Bennie!

Wednesday's press conference was, in my opinion, a stark confirmation of two big negatives for the economy and the markets:

1)  The Fed is out of ammo unless it resorts to Japanese style asset purchases and no, Mr. Chairman, that will not stimulate the economy.
2)  Bernanke is completely lost in monetary theory and does not understand what is really going on in the banking system he is supposed to oversee.

Both of these issues mean that, if you can't short the market, cash is a great play until central bankers step away from the dope.  Sadly, much more damage could be done before that happens.


Ed Pawelec signature
Ed Pawelec
Contributing Editor
Price Shock Trader
36 votes
Thumbs Up! Thumbs Down!
Thank you for voting!

Comments:

law

6/22/2012 4:29 PM

i am not so sure interest rates matter to a prop desk  they just know that liquidity will  be there for a rising market  the 60 year cycles and 26 year cycles are pure beauty to study 
Ganeshsastri

6/22/2012 4:33 PM

Why not CONSOLIDATE the financial statements of FED and TREASURY? Just as we consolidate the finances of HOLDING & SUBSIDIARY companies, so should we consolidate the finances of FED & TREASURY. When you do that FED buying TREASURY is nullified and the tru
Lwb

6/22/2012 4:56 PM

For those that cannot short the market in traditional ways, why couldn't ETF's that short the market be purchased and used?
FollowTheFacts

6/22/2012 5:18 PM

...glad to hear it... ("cash is a great play") "...They are swinging for the fences and double-digit returns through speculation in obscure derivatives...." (...the banks) ...and that in itself, is evidence of advanced stage societal rot... Other than tha
Nick

6/22/2012 5:11 PM

a good explanation [ if its true ] most of us don't understand how the Federal Reserve work, and the benefit if any. I ask --if its true --not to be nasty but one has to question every thing they read, other then when Obama speaks of course--LOL
truthwatcher2

6/22/2012 5:10 PM

Good analysis, but lose some of the low level cracks.  You will never be doing, "stand-up." any time soon.   In my opinion, you either think you are a , "smart-ass," or, are attempting to cover up your shortcomings.  Which is it? @caf980ba77245e8d796
Traveler555

6/22/2012 6:16 PM

What we need to do in Nationalize the Federal Reserve to get it out of private hands. The Treasury can than Print U.S notes which do not provide interest payments to the Owners of the Federal Reserve Banks which are Federal in name only but are owned by p
Bignfootlaw

6/22/2012 8:49 PM

look the BS BS BS is  BS.....these people got US to this place.....they want to keep us here... WTF UP WTF UP...USA is sold down the river....when it crashes i hop eit burns to ashes....so we canstart over again... BUT are we smarter thna a 5th grader...
Dejack

6/22/2012 8:58 PM

Makes sense !!!
Kenders222

6/22/2012 9:40 PM

Your article bashes the fed chairman but does't offer any solutions. Poking fun of his name is childish.
law

6/22/2012 9:48 PM

if you have ever lived in Mexico you know they use the banks  banks to socialize their losses on the backs of the uninformed' no different here  you know you are not an insider if your losses are not socialized by your amigo el reservo
chrys

6/23/2012 2:32 AM

CASH?!?!? REALLY!?!?! I think not.  Nothing is more devalued by QE (in any of its forms) than fiat currencies. Two of the last remaining bubbles left to pop are debt and currency - especially sovereign debt and US dollars and Euros. Better move is into
Gthompson

6/23/2012 6:29 AM

Give me a break, they have known the results of their actions from day 1. Our founding fathers fought the same thing 200 years ago private bankers {the Federal Reserve, bank of London etc etc throughout the world} strangling what we used to know as capita
Normsw

6/23/2012 7:38 AM

Just another example of the fact that the idiots running the nation's money don't have a clue how to fix the econony. Spend and borrow is their mantra, digging the financial hole deeper and miring the US in a long-term no-growth situation.
Budenglish

6/23/2012 3:04 PM

Good article.
Mukleedavisson

6/23/2012 4:20 PM

I have been watching this government in action since the late 70's and needless to say I am not impressed with neither party. It's simple there are no partie's there are the have's and the have not's(simple). In my opinion if you really want to spurr the
Thomas Paine

6/23/2012 5:58 PM

try some LSD and tell me what you think then... dump all paper and get back to gold standard. It just so happens to be LAWFUL MONEY,as opposed to LEGAL TENDER. Sorry, didn't mean to scare you
Ardmeen42

6/24/2012 10:57 AM

Further to your historical article about " Continentals"  there is a(seldom used now ) e[pression  of derision which goes " I couldn't give a Continental about - insert topic -   among the older generation in Australia.One presumes a connection
Todd_virta

6/24/2012 6:26 PM

This was a great piece...No bullets in the gun...no breaks on the bus, the zombie banks are chasing them and the fiscal cliff is coming up fast! We are going to see panic in the country of biblical proportions! The fed will try the congress with try but t
Johnbug37

6/25/2012 2:48 PM

You would do well to curb your attacks on the person and focus more on the content of your points. If you have all the answers, you should be in Bernanke's position with all the responsibilities.  You view of the facts might be a little different.
Cgm205

6/25/2012 11:38 PM

Another, I think,  prescient article showing the direction Bennie seems to want to take us.  The last 2 negatives are enough to make one want to rush out and buy gold.